Zendaya: B+
Zendaya
Nina Prommer/Shutterstock
When Poison Ivy is the main inspiration, things can get tangled quickly (we’re talking rashes here). But the ultra-fitted corset and sleeved skirt gives a vampy take on a look that would otherwise be costume-y.
Billy Porter: B-
Billy Porter
Rob Latour/Shutterstock
There is something very cartoonish about this. Porter has gained carte blanche thanks to his repeated success with nontraditional red carpet dressing. But this hat is more appropriate for a remake of Scaramouche.
Gwendoline Christie: D
Gwendoline Christie
Shutterstock
If she’s going for the supernatural Lady Marian apparition look — or a holy church statue — then she’s walking on water. But for the mortals, this is a very frightening horror B-movie look.
Mandy Moore: B+
Mandy Moore
Shutterstock
She’s very Eighties evening soap in this pink-and-red, big hair, smoky-eye number. The cheese factor is offset by the timeliness with runway trends at the moment — and she’s owning it.
Maisie Williams: A-
Maisie Williams
Shutterstock
This is the first time that she’s gone young edgy fashion girl, a grown-up take from her usual anti-Establishment teenage look. This cool red carpet moment will open lots of doors for her, fashion-wise.
Phoebe Waller-Bridge: B+
Phoebe Waller-Bridge
Shutterstock
The best thing about this dress is it matches so well with